Earlier Posts, Nature
Leave a Comment

“Trees and the Wild”: Matt Pond, the American Pastoral and the Sublime [Condensed Version]

*The article below is a shortened version of a conference paper of the same name that I presented at the Popular Culture Association/American Culture Association National Conference held in New Orleans, LA on April 4, 2015. Additionally, the presentation is portion a longer work exploring the role of musicians in the twenty-first century speaking to the idea of the landscape in American culture.

Scholars show that American culture, in part, developed around the people’s reaction to nature and the wilderness. Americanist Henry Nash Smith describes the pull of the frontier in Virgin Land (1950), Perry Miller depicts a nature-manipulated change in the Puritan mind in Errand into the Wilderness (1956), and cultural variations are explored in Roderick Frazier Nash’s meticulous search for American interpretation and interaction with the outdoors in Wilderness and the American Mind (1965). This nature-driven response permeates American cultural production. American nature, and the wilderness, serves as an unavoidable topic of discussion when asking the question, “Who – or what – is America?”

In the nineteenth century, Ralph Waldo Emerson reflected on man’s relationship to the natural world as an essential component to human survival and nourishing spirituality. Transcendentalism was a reaction to the rationalism of eighteenth-century Enlightenment, as well as a revisiting of man’s relationship with the sublime in nature. Today we see a return to a connection with the environment as a result of a tremendously technological landscape, and while Americans are not willing to live the naturalist lifestyle of John Muir, sentiments of yearning for nature and the wilderness emerge in twenty-first century cultural production. The music and lyrics of the northeastern American songwriter Matt Pond serves as a case for sentiments of the pastoral and the sublime as he reaches to the language of the natural world to illustrate love and life in the twenty-first century.

Matt Pond formed Matt Pond PA in Philadelphia and the band released their first album Deer Apartments in 1998. Over the course of sixteen years, Pond released nine full-length albums and nine EPs, with members of the band shifting as the years go on. Simply looking at the album titles, one can see that Pond’s aesthetics are rooted in natural elements: The Nature of Maps (2002), The Dark Leaves (2010), Spring Fools EP (2011) are such examples. The cover art for the album Emblems (2004) contains the silhouette of a deer in mid-leap along a landscape of collaged mountains and rolling hills. Notably, markers of technology are evident in the image.

Matt Pond PA, Emblems album art (2004)

Matt Pond PA, Emblems album art (2004)

The tops of power lines peek through the slopes. The flatness of the image, due to the stylized deer and landscape, is enhanced by the paper-like texture of each segment. The “sky” is vertically striped green and the land is varying shades of blue – opposite of the natural world. The white figure of the deer in the center of the picture also creates a contrast to nature. Not a shadow, the body serves as a window. Clearly, the tension of nature and technology is evident in the Emblems album art. Though a more conclusive and direct relationship between Pond’s worldview and the natural world is evident in an analysis of his song lyrics.

The Pastoral

In The Machine in the Garden, Leo Marx describes the contradiction between urban developments and the captivation of the serene, if slightly developed, pastoral landscape of the farmers as the primary moving force of the frontier in the nineteenth century. At the core of his argument is the tension between nature and technology. Marx works his thesis through the myth-symbol method and draws evidence from literature and visual art. In an analysis of Pond’s lyrics, the goal is not to support the myth-symbol process, but to locate in contemporary music a similar sentiment of pastoral fascination. Writing of post-1960s American music, ecomusicologist David Ingram asserts, “The pastoral mode has come to dominate American musical representations not only of the rural, ‘middle’ landscape, but also of wilderness” and “like the pastoral mode, American popular music itself is an urban product.” [1] As Marx declares that the pastoral obsession existed due to its difference from the urban, so American music can prioritize the pastoral as a difference from the technology – and even location – that produces it.

When asked about his writing process in relation to the natural environment, Pond responded with an explanation that in his early songwriting he “unintentionally juxtaposed [his] urban environment with [his] upstate New York.” That it was strange to hear others perceive him as a “naturalist,” but over time he has come to accept and acknowledge his “original perception of beauty.”[2]

Pond may not use pastoral language necessarily for political purposes, he employs bucolic poetry to manage more difficult emotions. Ingram’s analysis of musical aesthetics established in political or social activism is limited and does not cover the full range of creative possibilities. Pond’s lyrics represent the pastoral as metaphor for interpersonal relationships.

Pond describes the natural world as a place of life-giving mystery in the song “Specks” from the album The Dark Leaves. He is in awe of the beauty in nature, and importantly, how it is significantly intertwined with intimate relationships. Pond unites his belief in natural miracles to a belief in personal connections.

Up above I see specks of silver in the evening sky
Specks of gold in the river running from the deep moonlight
See us shake in the wild distortion of the water’s waves
Still I know you’re in the darkness shining from a mile away

 When the sun starts coming through
Or when the cardinal chides the moon
I believe in energies, that no one has to see for us to prove
I believe in you and me and everything we’ll ever see and do

 Hear your voice come across the pillows, whisper sweet and low
In the dark we’re disappearing, in the dark we’ll go
Up above I see specks of silver in the evening sky
Specks of gold in the river running, from the deep moonlight

When the sun starts coming through…

 The rain pours down in a million rivers
All through the sand with the silver slivers
And it keeps on coming
How it gives my heart blood
How it gives my heart blood[3]

Here, more than any other song, Pond’s lyrics mirror Emerson’s transcendental ruminations. The nineteenth-century philosopher writes, “The stars awaken a certain reverence, because though always present, they are inaccessible; but all natural objects make a kindred impression, when the mind is open to their influence.”[4] Emerson’s ideas on nature stem from this sentiment: the natural world is visually available but distant, and the only way to fully grasp its power is by surrendering one’s mind to its stimulus. Pond repeats the theme of “energies” throughout his song as a distinctive connecting factor of all elements. The same force evident in the sky and water, and which rush through his body, bind nature and relationships together. It is the aesthetic comfort of nature – in its wild splendor – that grabs Pond’s attention. The “darkness” that pulls him is no match for the gold and silver energies, even if something is distorted by nature itself. That nature can serve as a language for human relationships is characteristic of Pond’s writing and routinely arises in his work.

Matt Pond speaks of nature as an extension of the human experience and the self/wilderness connection is a twenty-first century expansion on American transcendental ideals. Emerson’s theory, embedded in the natural world, was a response to his surroundings. Later through the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, the common denominator between Emerson and other American artists and thinkers is the land itself. Nature philosopher Aldo Leopold’s lyrical Sand County Almanac (1966) is not only a statement of theory, but also a work of prose, and his Land Ethic would be meaningless without its literary counterpart. His creative response to the land is what necessitates a moment of pause by the reader and allows for contemplation. Leopold writes, “That land is a community is the basic concept of ecology, but that land is to be loved and respected is an extension of ethics. That land yields a cultural harvest is a fact long known, but latterly often forgotten.”[5] The cultural harvest can be reaped through diverse methods: physical experience, visual representation, transcribed descriptions like Leopold’s, and through song. What matters is that the land exists and permeates our thoughts. In this way, Pond responds to the pastoral landscape, but he does not neglect the sublime.

The Sublime

To discuss an individual’s experience with nature necessitates not only an understanding of the pastoral, but of the sublime. A human being is outside the control of nature in the sublime. For the most part, Americans no longer engage with the wild on a daily basis like those who live in a less technological landscape, but the struggle for survival consumes our imagination. The sublime is a terrible experience, but also a fascinating one, pulling on an individual’s imagination while simultaneously requiring the employment of defense mechanisms.

It is challenging to uncover the sublime within Pond’s songs at first listen, because Pond typically does not employ overwhelming or fierce musical composition. His voice is pleasant, warm and welcoming. The strumming of the guitar is intimate. It is only when closely listening to the lyrics does one come away with a feeling of apprehension and restlessness. There is something not quite “right” with the world and Pond uses the environment as metaphor. “It is Safe” comes from the 2005 LP Several Arrows Later:

Let’s go for a swim out into the waves
When the lifeguards leave, it’s ours for the day
Let’s feel like we’re brave, let’s give it some meaning

Even if it is shallow, even if it is fake
It is safe as long as I see you way out in the water
With no thought of going under, we could be out here for hours

Lying in the sand I fall asleep and dream of the summer
When we’d slip behind the pool and go with nature
We’d lie beside the chlorine bottles after sometimes sleep
And dream of summer when things could not be so easy

If you’re looking for something out in the waves
At least it is something, you know that you’re safe.
It is sound as long as I see you way out in the water
With no thought of going under, we could be out here for hours
I see birds above the waves sit on the air and wait for something
I know someday I’ll be done with all this waiting
So I’ll ay down on the couch after sometime sleep
And dream of the summers when things could not be so terribly easy[6]

Here Pond juxtaposes the uneasy feelings of a stagnant relationship with the possibility of danger in the ocean. The third and fourth lines provide double meaning. The ambivalence in which Pond approaches the water and relationship through the word “it” is countered by the repetition of the word “safe.” It is “safe as long as I see you out in the water.” Simply by a turn of the head the security of both the relationship and his watchful protection the individual in the water could vanish. Lifeguards are nowhere to be found, so it is his responsibility to stay alert. Pond speaks toward the relationship that exists with ennui and the apathetic energies that can become precarious. The multi-dimensional language Pond uses to describe his wish to be free is complicated with the desire to stay safe. The sublime in “It is Safe” is found in the feeling, like standing at the edge of a cliff, with one small move everything can fall apart. Hope is crushed by indifference and apathy is a reaction to fear of potential loss.


Matt Pond is ideal for this analysis because he places at the forefront of his work language of nature, while not weighting his words with pretentious political or social messages. He may assert a different purpose for his work, but it is undeniably nature-speak. This creates a safe space for his listeners to enter in to an unaffected state of contemplation regarding their interaction with others and with the natural world.

I asked Pond if he felt like he was a part of an intellectual heritage in America. I wanted to know if he felt connected to other writers and artists through the ideas he proposes in his music. His answer was filled with humility and veneration for those who came before, but also he is concerned with how people may perceive him:

“Sometimes I think people want me to dress and speak the part of the person they imagine me to be. The flannel-clad woodsmen or the surly fur trapper, smudged with dirt, whiskey in hand. As if it were more authentic to pretend. I don’t consider myself a storyteller of a mythologized America. I don’t claim to know anything more than I know.[7]

No, Pond is not a naturalist, or a woodsman, or a radical environmental political activist. Often these assumptions are made against those who speak through nature. To say this is exclusive to American culture teases with Exceptionalism, but in truth, it is the language of Americans. From the beginning, New World settlers were impacted by their surroundings and it was evident in their writing. This place created a sort of Arcadian fantasy and sublime dream in the minds of New World Europeans. This intellectual heritage continues whether we are aware of it or not. Historians, such as Leo Marx, attempted to explain the obsession with nature that for so long has been designated as “truly American,” but little effort has been made to show the theory in practice in the twenty-first century. Matt Pond portrays the picturesque garden and the sublime wilderness and thus creates a sincerely American body of work.




Works Cited

Brady, Emily. The Sublime in Modern Philosophy: Aesthetics, Ethics, and Nature. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2013.

Davis, John. The Landscape of Belief: Encountering the Holy Land in Nineteenth-Century American Art and Culture. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1996.

Emerson, Ralph Waldo. “Nature,” Nature: Essays and Lectures, New York: Library of America 1983.

Ingram, David. The Jukebox in the Garden: Ecocriticism and American Popular Music. New York: Rodopi, 2010.

Leopold, Aldo. Sand County Almanac. New York: Ballantine Books, 1966.

Marx, Leo. The Machine in the Garden: Technology and the Pastoral Ideal in America. New York: Oxford University Press, 1964.

Pond, Matt. The Dark Leaves. Record. Performed by Matt Pond PA. 2010. Boulder, CO: Altitude Records. MP3.

_________. Several Arrows Later. Record. Performed by Matt Pond PA. 2005. Boulder, CO: Altitude Records. MP3.




[1] David Ingram, The Jukebox in the Garden: Ecocriticism and American Popular Music (New York: Rodopi, 2010): 52, 55.

[2] MP to SRW, Written Interview, March 2014.

[3] “Specks.” Matt Pond. The Dark Leaves. Record. Performed by Matt Pond PA. (2010. Boulder, CO: Altitude Records.) MP3.

[4] Ralph Waldo Emerson, “Nature,” Nature: Essays and Lectures (New York: Library of America, 1983).

[5] Aldo Leopold, Sand County Almanac (New York: Ballantine Books, 1966): xix.

[6] “It is Safe.” Matt Pond. Several Arrows Later. Record. Performed by Matt Pond PA. (2005. Boulder, CO: Altitude Records) MP3.

[7] MP to SRW, Written Interview, March 2014.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s